19 Petticoat Lane, Shelter Island, NY 11964
19 Petticoat Ln

19 Petticoat Ln

19 Petticoat Lane, Shelter Island, NY


  • 4 Beds
  • 2 Full Baths
  • 1 Half Bath
  • 1.6 Acres Lot
  • 2,030 Sq.Ft. Living
  • 1974 Year Built
  • For Rent Status
  • 870926 MLS® ID
STR#19H-0002 Nestled in the quieter part of Shelter Island, called Silver Beach, with little to no traffic in the autumn, this is a secluded and sheltered home with a wooded back yard, approximately 1.6 acres, welcoming birds and other wildlife especially when relaxing or swimming. This is also an ideal location for the autumn, if you are considering visiting the Vineyards of the North Fork. Having been renovated in 2014, this 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath Gambrel style home has a spacious open kitchen & modern appliances, 18 x 36 in ground pool (Memorial Day - Labor Day only), CAC; white-painted, airy, sunny, with wood-flooring, charcoal grill, working fireplace, and a short walk to a private beach with sunsets. The best of the Hamptons without the hassle.
Seasonal Rental
Period Price Dates Status
June $6,500 Jun 15th - Jun 30th 2022 Available
July $16,000 Jul 1st - Jul 31st 2022 Available
August-LD $19,000 Aug 1st - Sep 5th 2022 Available
Show MoreShow Less
Jonathan Milioti

Jonathan Milioti

Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
Julia Weisenberg

Julia Weisenberg

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

Features & Amenities


  • Total Bedrooms4
  • Total Bathrooms2.5
  • Full Bathrooms2
  • Half Bathrooms1
  • other interior FeaturesEat-In Kitchen, Granite Kitchen Counter, Oven/Range, Refrigerator, Dishwasher, Microwave, Washer, Dryer, Stainless Steel Appliance, Hot Water Heater, Hardwood Flooring, Ceramic Tile Flooring, Furnished, 8 Rooms, Living Room, Dining Room, Master Bedroom, Walk-in Closet, Bonus Room, Breakfast, 1 Fireplace, Wood Stove, Hot Water, 1 Heat/AC Zones, Gas Fuel, Oil Fuel, Central A/C

Area & Lot

  • Status For Rent
  • Living Area2,030 Sq.Ft.
  • Lot Area1.6 Acres
  • MLS® ID870926
  • TypeResidential
  • YEAR BUILT1974


  • other exterior FeaturesFrame Construction, Cedar Shake Siding, Asphalt Shingles Roof, Attached Garage, 2 Garage Spaces, Private Well Water, Private Septic, Pool: In Ground, Vinyl, Fencing, Pool Size: 18 x 36 ft, Fence, Outdoor Shower, Driveway, Trees, Pond View, Water Frontage: winter view only


As a real estate investors, owners, and landlords, we have made a career of our passion. With decades of professional and personal experience, we are experts in the process of buying, selling, and renting homes.

Contact Us